How to Turn a PR Crisis Into an Opportunity

Most brands don’t lose control in a crisis because of the event. They lose control because of how they respond to it. And in today’s media cycle, one wrong tone, one forced joke, or one poorly timed comment can make a manageable situation become significantly worse.


By Mark Macias
Founder of MACIAS PR | Former NBC Executive Producer


Not every crisis is an opportunity, and not every brand can turn a negative into a positive.

But when it is done right, the upside can be significant. Nestle’s recent handling of their KitKat crisis is a case study in how to leverage a crisis with an authentic message.

The Candybar Crisis: 400,000 Bars Stolen 

More than 4 tons of chocolate KitKat bars were stolen in Europe last week. 

It’s a negative headline – or is it?

Nestlé moved fast when the news broke and reframed the narrative with a single line:

“We’ve always encouraged people to have a break… but it seems thieves took that too literally.”

That response did three things immediately:

  • Acknowledged the issue (no hiding)
  • Controlled the tone (light, but appropriate)
  • Redirected the story (from theft → brand personality)

Within hours, other brands were joining in with their own memes and social media posts.

The story was no longer about a stolen product but how a product was in demand.


Where this Historically Goes Wrong

Many brands see a win like this and try to mimic the approach. It usually doesn’t work because the brand veers from its core with a new tone.

This happened with NFL quarterback Geno Smith after he was released from the Las Vegas Raiders.

Wendy’s tried to insert itself into the conversation with a joke about hiring Smith as their Chief Tasting Officer. The fast food chain failed miserably after Smith failed to play along. He responded quickly to their post, saying “ “Not until you get your cheese up.”

The power shifted. Wendy’s veered from its core with a new tone that made fun of someone for losing their job. Maybe that wasn’t their intention, but it’s how it came across. Also, Wendy’s wasn’t controlling the narrative — they were reacting to it.

As a result, they became part of the story in a way they didn’t intend.


The Crisis PR Playbook

If you’re leading a brand, here are some important points to remember.

1. Not every moment is yours

Just because something is trending doesn’t mean you belong in it. Nestlé had permission since it was their story. Their tone also matched their brand. If you have to force it, don’t do it.


2. Tone can make or break you

Humor works when:

  • stakes are low
  • no one is harmed
  • your brand is known for it

It fails when:

  • people are affected (health, jobs, safety)
  • emotions are high
  • you’re perceived as opportunistic

3. Move fast — or don’t move at all

There’s a small window in every crisis. Nestlé hit it. Miss that window, and your response feels reactive — not strategic.


4. Control the narrative early

If you don’t define the story, someone else will. And once that happens, you’re playing defense.


5. Think one step ahead

Before you publish anything, ask: “How could this backfire?” Because if there’s a way — it will.


Final thought

Yes, a crisis can become an opportunity but only if it’s handled with discipline.

The same move that makes one brand look sharp can make another look tone-deaf. And in this fast-paced environment, it happens so quickly that you rarely have time to adapt.

Need help changing the narrative of your crisis? Reach out to me to schedule a call.


ABOUT MACIAS PR

MACIAS PR was founded in 2009 by Mark Macias – an Executive Producer with NBC and Senior Producer with CBS in New York. City & State Magazine named Macias one of the top 50 best PR pros in New York in 2022 and 2024. Finance Monthly named MACIAS PR the 2017-2020 Strategic PR Firm of the Year, and PR Firm of the Year.